Fishing near Amagansett in Suffolk County, NY

3.73 Rating based on 24 Reviews
  • Most Caught Species: Scup (Porgy), Blackfish, Striped Bass, Black Sea Bass, Bluefish, Summer Flounder (Fluke)
  • # of fishing spots within 25 miles: 18
  • # of reports within 25 miles: 47
  •  
  • Discuss Amagansett area fishing in our New York Fishing Forum

Amagansett Fishing Photos

No Bones Just Blues near Amagansett

No Bones Just Blues

Added by: flyangler
View Full Size
Montauk Surf fishing near Amagansett

Montauk Surf fishing

Added by: kevwon
View Full Size
ferry shelter island south near Amagansett

ferry shelter island south

runs every 15 min
Added by: tsavfish
View Full Size
Plum Island Gut Fishing 2010 near Amagansett

Plum Island Gut Fishing 2010

Added by: davetroy
View Full Size
Chloe's Blue near Amagansett

Chloe's Blue

Added by: davetroy
View Full Size
Bluefish caught at Plum Gut near Amagansett

Bluefish caught at Plum Gut

Labor Day Weekend Bluefish
Added by: davetroy
View Full Size

Top Fishing Spots near Amagansett

Acabonack Harbor
Acabonack Harbor

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 1373

Napeague Bay
Napeague Bay

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 343

Gardiners Bay
Gardiners Bay

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 581

Shelter Island Sound
Shelter Island Sound

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 204

Plum Island Gut
Plum Island Gut

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 2548

Little Peconic Bay
Little Peconic Bay

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 404

Amagansett Area Fish Species

Recent Amagansett Fishing Reports

No Bones just blues 8-19-2009 Fishing Report Aug 19, 2009

No Bones just blues 8-19-2009

Gardiners Island Ny -

With a recent report of Bonito in the waters around Gardiners Island, left the dock at 1st light :30 this morning. Anticipation was high for the first...

Avg. Rating: 3
# Reviews: 5 Views:
Review Report
Created by: flyangler
Map It
Plum Gut Fishing Report Sep 05, 2010

Plum Gut

Plum Island Gut -

Fished Plum Island Gut for Blues and Stripers with Chloe over the Sunday of Labor Day weekend 2010. Unfortunately, Hurricane Earl had hit (weakly) on...

Avg. Rating: 5
# Reviews: 1 Views:
Review Report
Created by: davetroy
Map It
T-Man Charter July 2, 2007 Fishing Report Jul 23, 2007

T-Man Charter July 2, 2007

My boys and I went with Capt. Pat to learn the fine points of the Tube & Worm. Stripers Beware! We caught 7 in less than an hour, 4 keepers includ...

Avg. Rating: 5
# Reviews: 1 Views:
Review Report
Created by: rbwizard
Map It
Gardiners Island NY Fishing Report Jul 02, 2009

Gardiners Island NY

Garniers Island NY -

Fly Rodding the Flats for stripers using epoxy sand eel imitations...

Avg. Rating: 4
# Reviews: 4 Views:
Review Report
Created by: flyangler
Map It
Plum Island Fishing Report Jun 30, 2009

Plum Island

Plum Island NY -

Plum Island and the Sluiceway...

Avg. Rating: 4
# Reviews: 5 Views:
Review Report
Created by: flyangler
Map It
operation montauk Fishing Report Jul 20, 2009

operation montauk

montauk, NY -

taking 3 ferrys to the tip of long island in search of a 50 lb striper from the surf...

Avg. Rating: 5
# Reviews: 5 Views:
Review Report
Created by: tsavfish
Map It

Baits and Tackle used near Amagansett

Check Prices

  • spearing squid strip
  • sea robin
  • live sand worms
  • Squid
  • live worms
  • eel
  • Kastmaster
  • soft shad killers on a jig-head. black/silver color pattern.
  • live bait

Live Bait (Other) Check Prices

  • Clams
  • eel, frozen squid
  • live eals
  • eel
  • Sandworms and Squid

Tube Check Prices

  • Only hitting the tube and worm. Fish on every 50-100 yard run.
  • tube and worm (sand worm)

Roundhead Jig Check Prices

  • i was using a keitech 2" spider, and my partner was throwing there 4" worm. Both were working

Saltwater Spoon Check Prices

  • deadly dick,hopkins

Saltwater Fly Check Prices

  • Olive Flat wing deceiver, popper
  • Sight casting to stripers on the flats off Garniers Island Ny
  • Epoxy Bay Anchovie Pattern Size 2
  • Fly Fishing - Rootbeer estaz and white marabou tied on a 1/0 hook wooly bugger style. Stripers and blues were feeding on nickle sized butterfish and peanut bunker
  • Platium Blonde 1/0 and olive flatwing deceiver 1/0
  • Flatwing Deceiver
  • Stripers surface feeding on quarter size Butterfish from dawn until about 8:30AM
  • Flies- Platinum Blonde 1/0, Gray white Flat wing Deceiver2/0 chartruese Closar 1/0

Lure (Other) Check Prices

  • Tube & Worm

Jigs Check Prices

Saltwater Swimbait Check Prices

Bass Jig Check Prices

  • my regular watermelon red flake

Soft Swimbait Check Prices

Casting & Trolling Spoon;22 Check Prices

  • Blue/silver Castmaster with bucktail

Herring Check Prices

  • Chunks of Atlantic menhaden
  • Fresh Chunked Herring

Squid Check Prices

  • 4 oz
  • Spinner rigs with colored beads and buck tail fished along the bottom with a squid strip and spearing added
  • sabikis
  • frozen squid
  • put a sinker on it and dropped it to the bottom

Saltwater Baits Check Prices

  • Green crabs cut in half
  • Green crabs cut in half on a 4/0
    Gamakatsu Octopus hook

Jigging Spoon Check Prices

  • Silver Diamond Jigs

Saltwater Jig Check Prices

  • jigs
  • sqid
  • squid
  • Hammered Jig
  • gulp
  • skate
  • braid jig shiners squid strips
  • strips

Topwater Bait (Popper, Plug) Check Prices

  • BLUE/WHITE POPPER

Marabou / Bucktail Jig Check Prices

  • Green bucktail with red pork rind on 3way
  • Bucktails tipped with Squid/spearing. Brian caught the 9lber on bait rod with large silverside
  • Bucktail tipped with squid/spearing

Worm Check Prices

  • used both watermelon and green pumpkin
  • watermelon gold flake

Other Check Prices

  • buck tails yellow or white with pork rind trailer , yellow darters, slingging eels at night
  • frozen spearing
  • crabs
  • greenies
  • blue crab on chicken
  • chicken
  • blue crab!

Stay Updated

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to stay updated on Amagansett fishing and other New York fishing. You'll also receive community updates, invites to try new features and promotions from our partners.

NY Fish Finder

Social Links