Lower Mystic Lake Fishing Report

4.93 Rating based on 15 Reviews

Lower Mystic Lake Smallie Fishing

Once again I had smallie's on my brain so I headed to the closest place I know that has them. Lower Mystic lake. I've never done much here. Some small Larry's but that's about it. I took a right from the launch and started right at the dam throwing a deep diving crank. Nothing I set the trolling motor on low and just started going down the shore line alternating between the deep crank, a squarebill KVD and a jig. I mixed a double bladed buzz in there for fun. No takers for like an hour and a half. I passed by the river entrance and headed back toward the launch. I was in 20 ft of water cranking a deep diving crank (bomber I think) and finally hooked up with a dink LMB. It's a start. Next cast I catch a 1 1/2 pound LMB. Getting better. A couple of casts later the lure gets stuck on the bottom and breaks off. Crap. Tie on another one and continue. Nothing. I switch to the squarebill and feel a hit. I set the hook and a dink smallie makes a jump. Ok at least I found what I was looking for. It was getting dark so I kicked up the trolling motor and started fishing faster. Nothing. As I was getting closer to the launch I decided to make a few more casts at the damn. Water is flowing from the upper lake and pouring into the lower with like a 2 foot waterfall stirring up the water. I cast a KVD squarebill sexy shad right into the froth. Wham! it gets hit right away. I set the hook and know it's huge. I was still thinking smallie and my mind was telling me 6-7 pounder. It kept making runs and stripping drag. As I got it closer to the boat I got a good look at it. STRIPER!!! My heart was pumping. I had it next to the boat and every attempt to net him failed as he kept surging and the popped off the hook. Crap. Next cast I put in the same spot. Wham! another fish on. I fight it again. Get it to the boat and it breaks off my KVD. I was about to tie on another crank when White Lightning stepped up. I loosened the drag and cast my jig to the same spot. Wham!!! This is unbelievable. Fish on. He's pulling me all around, stripping line. I fight him to the boat for the third time and this time I'm gonna lip him (no trebles) and pull him in. This is so awesome I actually take my iphone 5 out of it's waterproof case to take a pic (which still didn't come out great). I made a bunch more cast with the jig with no luck so I tied on another crank, get hit and the fish throws it. It's really dark now so I get outta there. I'm pretty sure I'll be back.

  • Added By: shawneramone on 10/17/12 09:39 PM
  • Location: Lower Mystic Lake
  • Report Date: 10/17/2012
  • # of Photos: 2
  • Learn more about Lower Mystic Lake fishing in our fishing message boards

Report Photos

... shawneramone posted in MA
0
11y
... shawneramone posted in MA
10
11y

Report Map

Stay Updated

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to receive New York fishing reports right in your inbox. You'll also receive community updates, invites to try new features and promotions from our partners.

Comments

  • The jig was green

  • ok, spill it, what color was the jig?

  • Yes it is Shawn. I stand corrected and have now seen a smallie caught, albeit a blurry one !

  • True Smoke. I fished a ton this year! Imagine I went striper fishing 5 or 6 times on the Harbor with no stripers caught. Then I catch one in a lake.

  • Roger I know it's kind of blurry but the other pic is a smallie

  • i caught a giant carp on a crankbait not too long ago. it was fun for the first 5 minutes then it sucked. 10 lb. test on a crankbait rod...

  • there are HUGE catfish at the dam as well.

  • Roger, you have to actually go there to see these things. As for the stripers, Arlington bait is loaded with striper pics from down there.

  • For what its worth Shawn, I've never seen a smallie caught there either. Maybe it's time for you to show me one of those now too! Go get em' killah!

  • Shawn you will never catch them when you target them. They are just an added bonus over there.

NY Fish Finder

Social Links