Chestnut Hill Reservoir Fishing Report

5 Rating based on 4 Reviews

Father & Daughter Trip To Chestnut Hill Res

Last Saturday I took my daughter fishing at Chestnut hill reservoir. It was a cold overcast morning but the fish where out. She is getting more interested and mature about fishing...she asked me to check the reel and put some WD-40 on it to keep it casting smoothly. I had her start out throwing the Vibrax minnow spin but she felt that it wasn't fishing deep enough so she tied (herself) a size 8 crappie hook with Berkeley honey on it. She had me set the depth on the bobber and started casting at the bluegills.

She got frustrated because she kept missing strikes, I took her rig and demonstrated how to set the hook again and reeled in my first Bluegill of the season. I gave the rig back to her so that she could try again. Two casts later she hooked up with her first Bluegill of the 2011.

Then the bite shut off. So we move to the spot with the tree over hanging the shore, where she caught her first carp. Then she caught another 'gill but he took the bait and hook.

I tied on a Bomber A that a pickerel struck but did not hook up. So I downed sized to a 3' silver rebel value minnow and hooked up with 7" inch pickerel.

We got cold so we left before lunch time.

  • Added By: thorn168 on 05/21/11 08:52 PM
  • Location: Chestnut Hill Reservoir
  • Report Date: 5/14/2011
  • # of Hotspots: 1
  • # of Photos: 0
  • # of Fish Caught: 5
  • Learn more about Chestnut Hill Reservoir fishing in our fishing message boards

Report Catches

Bluegill, Carp & Pick Catch

  • # of Fish Caught: 5
  • Water Type: freshwater
  • Type of Fish: Common Carp
  • Fish Length (Avg): 5 inches
  • Bait Type: Other Check Prices
  • Bait Details: Natural Berkley Honey worm

Report Map

Stay Updated

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to receive New York fishing reports right in your inbox. You'll also receive community updates, invites to try new features and promotions from our partners.

NY Fish Finder

Social Links